If you want an easier installation, I suggest Red Hat 5.0.
It allows for "kickstart" installation, making the installation of
similar configurations (ideal for networks) faster and more efficient.
B@N
On Thu, 19 Feb 1998 09:57:11 -0500
Tom Schaefer <netd(a)fastrans.net> wrote:
>
> We're de-Microsofting a few machines here ... and I'm getting much more
> familiar with the install process.
>
> Now I know I'm being a big pain in the ass here, but I went through the
> entire install and stopped to bug you along the way.
>
> One of the things you guys need to be aware of is that there are some
> 200 million Microsloth PCs out there, vs 8 - 20million Linux/Unix
> systems. The more you can streamline the install process and refer to
> things the way people are used to in Microsloth-land, the more
> acdeptable your distribution will be. I would suggest NOT defaulting to
> FVWM2, rather FVWM95. I know many Unix power users prefer the FVWM
> window manager, but you should have a screen in Yast that lets the user
> pick one, but default to FVWM95, this is what "the unwashed masses" are
> used to.
>
> Here are "a few" suggestions to streamline the install process.
>
> Let me preface my comments though with one thing I learned a long time
> ago in Configuration Management Land - a job I did for our pitiful
> US Postal Service rolling out Windoze 3.1 systems .... :
> NEVER TAKE A USER TO A MENU UNLESS YOU WANT THEM TO MAKE CHOICES.
> Thusly, if there really is no choice in a situation, then perform the
> next step and get on with the install.
>
> 1. After the first CD has completed, you have the system sitting there
> with a very small message in the lower left- hand corner of the screen
> saying "INSTALLATION COMPLETE". This is erroneous because we all know
> that we still have 2 CDs to go. Plus, you have the user sitting there
> with a full menu of choices and no direction on where to go, not a good
> idea.
>
> Make the message "INSTALLATION COMPLETE" go away and say something else,
> like, "PHASE ONE COMPLETE". Now rather than expecting the user to know
> what to do next, you should automatically pull the install forward to
> the next step: SuSEconfig. I suppose you could put a status message and
> a "Press enter to continue", but it's not really necessary.
>
> This is where a lot of people screw up. This is where I, back when I
> was new to SuSE, would (erroneously) go to INSTALL PACKAGES because SuSE
> skipped the 2nd and 3rd CDs, when I should have gone to Main Menu.
> You've got it high-lited, but that's not good enough for tinkers. We see
> that 2 and 3 didn't make it, so we're going to try and figure out why.
>
> 2. Since after the first CD, you want to run SuSEconfig, then why not
> just run it? (Stop and prompt user only for errors) This can be pulled
> to automatically, and also there should be no need to hit "Continue" at
> the end of SuSEconfig either, unless some sort of error occurs.
>
> 3.Next, after Suseconfig, you've got me back to another Main Menu, and
> no direction on where to go next. After having done a few SuSE
> installs, I now know that I need to hit "Finish Installation" - so why
> don't you just pull the user to the next step. By taking the user to a
> menu with vague choices you are introducing yet-another-failure-point in
> the install process. Newbie dies here too easily.
>
> 4.Next we are at "Select Kernel". You need a Help Screen here, because
> the user needs a quick reference to how the kernels have ben gen'd.
> Experienced users know what they want here, and a quick ref would be
> nice. Newbies will die here also. In fact, a selection to review what
> has been autoprobed would be nice at this point so I can get the right
> kernel - perhaps Yast could make a "suggested kernel" based upon
> autoprobing.
>
> 5. When you get to the choice of GMT or Local Time, perhaps you could
> default to Local Time, since 99.90f PCs are set to local time in CMOS.
>
> Now - no other distribution has this, but would be nice is a field to
> just enter "EST5CDT" or whatever time zone you want, rather than having
> to wade through the list. (Just a small suggestion, we're not dying
> here)
>
> 6. "Real Network" should be the default, not "Loopback"..
>
> 7.After DNS config, sendmail, you're running SuSEconfig again. Then we
> have another "Installation Complete" message, further imprinting in my
> mind that all the software has been loaded. Wrong.
>
> 8. Then we're back to the "Start Install" menu - and if we're running
> this on a slow system, it takes acouple of seconds to get the "... the
> new system will be started ..." message. You oughta just start it!
>
>
> 9."Probably Yast has to configure some things" - PROBABLY? What do you
> mean 'probably'? In English, this sounds like you're not really sure.
> "Yast is running, stand by ..." would be a better message.
>
> 10. "Example User" - Perhaps you should refer to this as "Default User
> Profile". This lines up with current 'market' i.e. Microsloth thinking.
>
> 11.Next, we have a "Confirmation" message telling me that 'during the
> last session the following packages could not be installed'.
> A better way to present this would be to say "We are now ready to finish
> the software load. The following packages are from the 2nd and 3rd CDs,
> which could not be mounted earlier in the install ...."
>
> 12.Then we get to a rather senseless screen about dependencies. Since
> hitting "AUTO" does nothing, why not just run through the dependencies
> automatically and get on with it! A small "Checking dependencies ...
> please stand by ..." message would suffice.
> Then, get me to the prompt for CD 2 , load software, then CD 3 ... blah
> blah blah ...
>
> 13. At the end of CD 3, we have the "INSTALLATION COMPLETE" message
> again, and no direction other than "TAB/ESC = Menu" . Newbie response:
> "Well, what should I do?" Why not have it go directly to the next
> screen "All installed packages are initialized..." instead of sitting at
> the previous screen ... in fact, even better would be to just run
> SuSEconfig and get on with it.
>
> (you're addressing this next item in the next release I think - but I'm
> including this for reference)
>
> 14. After SuSEconfig, we're sitting at a login prompt. Newbie: "Now
> what, should I login?" Probably not, (and because I, as an experienced
> installer; now, knew to ALT-F9 to see what's up. Ah, SuSE is 'doing
> something' ... (unpackingman pages, window manager configs). You need a
> message after that last SuSEconfig to tell newbie what's going on again.
> Newbie's not sure what the hell you guys are up to at this point, you've
> had him hitting 'Continue' and un-intuitively GUESSING which menu
> selections to hit - Newbie is exhausted and brain dead at this point.
> Without knowing to hit ALT-F9 he's gonna screw something up again.
>
> Perhaps you can streamline and background the whole thing, so that it's
> more transparent to the user. For example, even if they have rebooted,
> you guys run that "Probably Yast has to configure some things ..."
> message. PROBABLY? Aren't you sure? (Again- bad English) :-) I would
> run it in background - a simple "Yast is finishing the unpacking of man
> pages" (or what ever it's doing) and then let the system continue to
> boot up without incindent or need for user intervention. You can do all
> that shit as a background process with very little fanfare.
>
> Sorry for being a big pain in the ass with all this, but I believe this
> is better to be specific than just whining! :)
>
> Again, you folks have the best distribution, and your support in this
> list has been excellent. Kudos to you guys for responding
> dispassionately to my whining and complaining (as well as the others!) .
>
> We all have high expectations for Linux, as well as SuSE, and we want to
> see you succeed.
>
> Keep up the good work!
>
> -tks-
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> --
> To get out of this list, please send email to majordomo(a)suse.com with
> this text in its body: unsubscribe suse-linux-e
>
--
To get out of this list, please send email to majordomo(a)suse.com with
this text in its body: unsubscribe suse-linux-e