[opensuse-packaging] Need help with a rejected license mmlibs glew
Not wanting to have to submit again and again, glew was rejected by licensedigger. It had " ; Other uncritical OpenSource License" in every license field and I've removed that but it still has "BSD3c(or similar) ; GPLv2" the output from licencecheck is : glew-1.5.8/src/glewinfo.c: BSD (2 clause) glew-1.5.8/src/visualinfo.c: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/src/glew.c: BSD (2 clause) glew-1.5.8/include/GL/glew.h: BSD (2 clause) MIT/X11 (BSD like) glew-1.5.8/include/GL/glxew.h: BSD (2 clause) MIT/X11 (BSD like) glew-1.5.8/include/GL/wglew.h: BSD (2 clause) glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glewinfo_wgl.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glxew_head.h: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_tail.h: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_init_tail.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/khronos_license.h: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_head.h: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_init_gl.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glewinfo_tail.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_str_wgl.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glxew_tail.h: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_str_head.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_utils.c: BSD (2 clause) glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_utils.h: BSD (2 clause) glew-1.5.8/auto/src/wglew_tail.h: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_init_wgl.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/mesa_license.h: MIT/X11 (BSD like) glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glewinfo_head.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_license.h: BSD (2 clause) glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glewinfo_glx.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/wglew_head.h: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_str_tail.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glewinfo_gl.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_str_glx.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_head.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_init_glx.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/lib/OpenGL/Spec.pm: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_header.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_init.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_info_list.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/fix_OML_sync_control.sh: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_list.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_struct_fun.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/update_ext.sh: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/update_registry.sh: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/parse_spec.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_str.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_def_var.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_info.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_struct_var.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_def_fun.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_html.pl: UNKNOWN Thanks Dave P -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: opensuse-packaging+unsubscribe@opensuse.org For additional commands, e-mail: opensuse-packaging+help@opensuse.org
I have an updated package (1.6.0) at home:ketheriel:ayatana/glew, and I believe that glew is licensed under BSD and MIT, I don't really find any other mention in the documentation provided with the package. NM On Sat, Apr 30, 2011 at 7:23 PM, Dave Plater <davejplater@gmail.com> wrote:
Not wanting to have to submit again and again, glew was rejected by licensedigger. It had " ; Other uncritical OpenSource License" in every license field and I've removed that but it still has "BSD3c(or similar) ; GPLv2" the output from licencecheck is : glew-1.5.8/src/glewinfo.c: BSD (2 clause) glew-1.5.8/src/visualinfo.c: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/src/glew.c: BSD (2 clause) glew-1.5.8/include/GL/glew.h: BSD (2 clause) MIT/X11 (BSD like) glew-1.5.8/include/GL/glxew.h: BSD (2 clause) MIT/X11 (BSD like) glew-1.5.8/include/GL/wglew.h: BSD (2 clause) glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glewinfo_wgl.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glxew_head.h: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_tail.h: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_init_tail.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/khronos_license.h: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_head.h: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_init_gl.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glewinfo_tail.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_str_wgl.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glxew_tail.h: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_str_head.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_utils.c: BSD (2 clause) glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_utils.h: BSD (2 clause) glew-1.5.8/auto/src/wglew_tail.h: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_init_wgl.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/mesa_license.h: MIT/X11 (BSD like) glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glewinfo_head.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_license.h: BSD (2 clause) glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glewinfo_glx.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/wglew_head.h: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_str_tail.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glewinfo_gl.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_str_glx.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_head.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/src/glew_init_glx.c: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/lib/OpenGL/Spec.pm: *No copyright* UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_header.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_init.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_info_list.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/fix_OML_sync_control.sh: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_list.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_struct_fun.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/update_ext.sh: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/update_registry.sh: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/parse_spec.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_str.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_def_var.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_info.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_struct_var.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_def_fun.pl: UNKNOWN glew-1.5.8/auto/bin/make_html.pl: UNKNOWN
Thanks Dave P -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: opensuse-packaging+unsubscribe@opensuse.org For additional commands, e-mail: opensuse-packaging+help@opensuse.org
-- Nelson Marques /* As cicatrizes lembram-nos de onde estivemos, mas não ditam para onde vamos */ -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: opensuse-packaging+unsubscribe@opensuse.org For additional commands, e-mail: opensuse-packaging+help@opensuse.org
On 04/30/2011 09:26 PM, Nelson Marques wrote:
I have an updated package (1.6.0) at home:ketheriel:ayatana/glew, and I believe that glew is licensed under BSD and MIT, I don't really find any other mention in the documentation provided with the package.
NM
Would you mind submitting it to home:plater instead of multimedia:libs otherwise I'll have twice as much work getting it to Factory. Thanks Dave P -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: opensuse-packaging+unsubscribe@opensuse.org For additional commands, e-mail: opensuse-packaging+help@opensuse.org
Dave, My package is here[1]. I've made this package for later inclusion in GNOME:Ayatana since I also need GLEWmx available, which is also provided by this package. I'm not sure if you also need GLEWmx. The package is built just like in Debian, first we build the regular GLEW libraries and install them, after this we build and install GLEWmx and package them in separate packages sharing the same development package. The most significative change is that I only use pkgconfig() calls, but that can be easilly reverted for backwards compatibility. Dave, take a look into it, if it suits you, I'll branch the one on mm:libs, update it and re-submit it :) NM [1] - https://build.opensuse.org/package/files?package=glew&project=home%3Aketheri... On Sat, Apr 30, 2011 at 8:56 PM, Dave Plater <davejplater@gmail.com> wrote:
On 04/30/2011 09:26 PM, Nelson Marques wrote:
I have an updated package (1.6.0) at home:ketheriel:ayatana/glew, and I believe that glew is licensed under BSD and MIT, I don't really find any other mention in the documentation provided with the package.
NM
Would you mind submitting it to home:plater instead of multimedia:libs otherwise I'll have twice as much work getting it to Factory. Thanks Dave P
-- Nelson Marques /* As cicatrizes lembram-nos de onde estivemos, mas não ditam para onde vamos */ -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: opensuse-packaging+unsubscribe@opensuse.org For additional commands, e-mail: opensuse-packaging+help@opensuse.org
On 04/30/2011 10:26 PM, Nelson Marques wrote:
Dave,
My package is here[1]. I've made this package for later inclusion in GNOME:Ayatana since I also need GLEWmx available, which is also provided by this package. I'm not sure if you also need GLEWmx.
The package is built just like in Debian, first we build the regular GLEW libraries and install them, after this we build and install GLEWmx and package them in separate packages sharing the same development package.
The most significative change is that I only use pkgconfig() calls, but that can be easilly reverted for backwards compatibility.
Dave, take a look into it, if it suits you, I'll branch the one on mm:libs, update it and re-submit it :)
NM
[1] - https://build.opensuse.org/package/files?package=glew&project=home%3Aketheri...
I will have a look, not sure if GLEWmx is needed but if a newer version of glew is available I might as well update it. I was worried that you were going to submit to multimedia:libs and someone else would accept it while I was sorting the license issue out. Watch this space for license news. Thanks Dave P
On Sat, Apr 30, 2011 at 8:56 PM, Dave Plater<davejplater@gmail.com> wrote:
On 04/30/2011 09:26 PM, Nelson Marques wrote:
I have an updated package (1.6.0) at home:ketheriel:ayatana/glew, and I believe that glew is licensed under BSD and MIT, I don't really find any other mention in the documentation provided with the package.
NM
Would you mind submitting it to home:plater instead of multimedia:libs otherwise I'll have twice as much work getting it to Factory. Thanks Dave P
-- To unsubscribe, e-mail: opensuse-packaging+unsubscribe@opensuse.org For additional commands, e-mail: opensuse-packaging+help@opensuse.org
participants (2)
-
Dave Plater -
Nelson Marques