As many of the questions I ask on this list will tell, I am fairly new to Linux..but I am learning. I would say this is the case for a lot of people. I am currently consulting for a medical facility that has employed me to evaluate their Information Technology needs. One of the issues that has come from that evaluation is the fact that the 'server' they are currently using is way outdated in both its hardware and operating system. Therefore, one of the first things we will do is get a new server. A true server. Now, here is the issue that I think Linux faces. This facility has been using the same software for the past 8+ years. They are used to it and they do not want to switch. I called the company that makes the software and asked if they were doing anything in the way of porting the software to run on Linux. The answer was "somewhat". Somewhat translates into "we have one facility that has actually found a way to port the software to Linux by themselves, but we do not support them." The key word here "unsupported". If the software company had said that they would/could support their software on Linux, we would already have the server and would probably be a Microsoft free medical facility by now. The reason... not because I don't like Microsoft (even though I really don't). The reason we would be M$ free is because we wouldn't need M$. I have 25 current and potential users in this facility. NONE of the current users that have machines do anything that cannot be done in Linux. Email (Evolution, Kmail, etc), occasional document (Ooo, ABIword, etc.), and browsing (Mozilla, Opera). The only reason we have to go with M$ is because the software company we currently use doesn't support. Mind you, the other facility already sees that the software will work with Linux, but the company we would be reliant on for support will not support it. This means, for the Server, we are looking at spending an extra $1500 for software and licensing than we would if we were to go with SuSE or Red Hat. And for each workstation we are spending an additional $500+ for software (Win XP and Office 2003). Naturally, since we are looking at 10+ new machines throughout the facility, my Administrator was pleased to hear about the possibility of Linux, and more than disappointed when I told him that we could not use it. Now, we do have alternatives. We can replace the software we are currently using. I looked into that and the closest comparable software package (direct competitor of the company we are using now) is between $15k and $20k for purchase and installation (and they probably don't support a Linux installation either). Long story short.. as long as consultants such as the one you spoke with are working for companies like the one that makes the software we use, then yes, Linux will have issues making it to the workstation and into the office space. In this case, the software company has no idea how the other facility ported Linux. Truth be told, I'm sure they don't want to know. These techs want that MCSE they put on their business cards after their names to mean something :-) But as long as people like you and I the others on this list continue to shed light on what is really going on; as long as we continue to show that there are alternatives, change will come. It may not be fast, but it is inevitable. -=Thinker On Thu, 2003-10-02 at 07:53, Gedi wrote:
I was at a training course a few days ago. Whilst the rest of the group I was with had wondered off to stretch their leg in the break, I ended up on a discussion with the consultant/training officer about Linux, Unix, programming etc...
He passed a comment that Linux would never make it make it into homes or even onto workstations. The average user will always want microsoft product and far too much investment has been made with microsoft as a whole to warrant changing. His argument was, he was a software developer mainly for industry and virtually 100% of his work is for microsoft based software, even though his company offers development on any platform.
Needless to say we ended up arguing!!
As this list is home to many industry proffesionals, I would love to hear your comments on this.
Was he correct??
Will Linux ever be a real threat to Microsoft, not just in industry, but in the household also?
----------------------------------------- Email provided by http://www.ntlhome.com/