On 05.12.2013 20:31, Bruno Friedmann wrote:
I can't believe that we are not able to know who do the work. Did we get real complaint about our top contributors getting not enough gratitude? Be just assured about one thing, even if a packager has pushed 10000 packages to factory, I will not blindly trust the 10001! And also I would be able to trust a first submission of a newcomer. There's NO difference in contribution.
The number also doesn't mean quality, nor constant quality of doing. If you read that karma points == number of packages, then you misread
Of course you can. But if some newcomer comes along and submits a new kernel, it will be reviewed *REALLY DEEPLY* to understand where he's coming from and what his intentions are. If Michal submits a new kernel, it won't be even reviewed beside the version number. That's just the plain truth at the moment. While you might be an exception, everyone else I know increases his expectations if people did good work in the past. E.g. I'll gladly install stuff from home:seife, but I will be very reluctant to register home:coolguy. I just don't know coolguy. this whole thing. You shouldn't have stopped at the subject I guess. Bruno, I respect your bad experiences with Karma systems and your strong opinion about it. But you could pay back some respect in actually trying to understand what we want to achieve. And while Robert calls it spoon feeding, the Karma discussion is a discussion unrelated to the staging projects workflow. It's two different proposals, that might work together or not. The openSUSE team will very likely not work on it in the upcoming future, but it's an idea worth presenting and discussing - and as others said it was discussed before because if done right it can help the community. Just as it helps other communities. Greetings, Stephan -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: opensuse-project+unsubscribe@opensuse.org To contact the owner, email: opensuse-project+owner@opensuse.org