->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> "Richard Mixon (qwest)" (rnmixon@qwest.net) wrote: ---------- [...] 3) It sounds like this is an software/BIOS raid adapter (e.g. promise, SI, highpoint, etc.), not a true hardware raid with XOR processor and RAM cache onboard. Some of them do have good linux drivers, but many are troublesome. From the BIOS it will appear the RAID volume is configured, but without the correct/working drivers (usually from the manufacturer, not SuSE) it will appear as two drives. Of course their Windows drivers work much better for some reason :( [...] <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<- Yes; It sounds that Promise, Highpoint, Silicon Image, GigaRAID,... are all firmware raid controllers. When the OS loads and overrides controller's bios with its own driver, you have exactly pure software raid! The only difference with formal software raid is that the array is managed by the driver, not by the OS kernel. Can you mention any true hardware raid chipsets? I believe with a true hw raid adaptor, the individual disks should be totally hidden for the OS; Am I correct? ->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> [...] 5) If none of the above works then use the Yast partitioning utility to partition the drives and mirror them as RAID 1 using software RAID. It will probably be somewhat faster than the builtin RAID chip, though not quite as convenient (IMHO - others can give you hundreds of reasons why software RAID is really better :). [...] <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<- Is "being faster" due to the fact that sw raid uses kernel optimizations while builtin raid uses driver optimizations? Thank you for your notice, Bahram Alinezhad, Rudehen, Tehran, Iran. __________________________________________________ Do You Yahoo!? Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around http://mail.yahoo.com
On Sat, 18 Dec 2004 07:14:02 -0800 (PST), Bahram Alinezhad <alineziad@yahoo.com> wrote:
->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> "Richard Mixon (qwest)" (rnmixon@qwest.net) wrote: ---------- [...] 3) It sounds like this is an software/BIOS raid adapter (e.g. promise, SI, highpoint, etc.), not a true hardware raid with XOR processor and RAM cache onboard. Some of them do have good linux drivers, but many are troublesome. From the BIOS it will appear the RAID volume is configured, but without the correct/working drivers (usually from the manufacturer, not SuSE) it will appear as two drives. Of course their Windows drivers work much better for some reason :( [...] <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<-
Yes; It sounds that Promise, Highpoint, Silicon Image, GigaRAID,... are all firmware raid controllers. When the OS loads and overrides controller's bios with its own driver, you have exactly pure software raid! The only difference with formal software raid is that the array is managed by the driver, not by the OS kernel.
Can you mention any true hardware raid chipsets?
I believe with a true hw raid adaptor, the individual disks should be totally hidden for the OS; Am I correct?
Correct, assuming that RAID has been configured. As for real hardware RAID, all of the SCSI raid cards I am familiar with do real hardware raid. There are numerous of them from lots of vendors. If you want hardware RAID for ATA drives, then the only one I know is 3ware, but I assume others exist. I don't know what the situation is for SATA raid. I'm guessing it is more like SCSI where all the solutions are hardware RAID. Greg -- Greg Freemyer
Hi everyone Fisrt of all I wan't to which every one who might be concerned : MERRY CHRISTMAS ! Sorry to the others ! And to EVERYONE (except chinese maybe !) HAPPY NEW YEAR ! Now start the question : The lab has bought a DELL PowerEdge SC420 server which include 2 SATA 160 Go HD... on an Adaptec RAID controller. I don't know yet exactly which Adaptec controller it is but what's sure IS : Both HD are not recognised during installation (Suse pro 9.1 DVD, 32 bit) If i disable the RAID in the BIOS... install perform OK (at least until now, YOU security update is on process) Is there a way to be able to use RAID on this computer without buying another RAID controller ? Is there a special driver I should download and use during install instead of the standards one ? Is SuSE 9.2 correcting the problem ? I would be grateful for any help or advice...this is my first RAID configuration (and my firsts SATA disks !!). Mirroring is most wanted in this situation, since the server will be a data server for all the department. Thanks to everyone Matthias __________________________________ Matthias Titeux, PhD INSERM U563 - CPTP Departement de Genetique fonctionnelle des maladies des epitheliums Batiment Lefebvre - 2eme etage CHU Purpan Avenue de Grande Bretagne 31059 Toulouse Cedex 03 FRANCE --------------- Tel: 33 (5) 62 74 45 03 _________________________________
Your question 100% revolves around the adaptec controller. So when you figure out what you have, re-post. FYI: It sounds like you have the hardware, just go into the controller's bios setup. I'm sure it will tell you there what kind of controller it is. FYI2: There is no way in the world I would use SUSE 9.1 in a production environment. The kernel was just too new at that point, and major changes had to be made to the userland tools. If SLES 9 is too expensive for you, then look at SUSE 9.2 Greg -- Greg Freemyer On Thu, 23 Dec 2004 18:53:26 +0100, Matthias Titeux <matthias.titeux@toulouse.inserm.fr> wrote:
Hi everyone Fisrt of all I wan't to which every one who might be concerned :
MERRY CHRISTMAS !
Sorry to the others !
And to EVERYONE (except chinese maybe !)
HAPPY NEW YEAR !
Now start the question :
The lab has bought a DELL PowerEdge SC420 server which include 2 SATA 160 Go HD... on an Adaptec RAID controller.
I don't know yet exactly which Adaptec controller it is but what's sure IS :
Both HD are not recognised during installation (Suse pro 9.1 DVD, 32 bit)
If i disable the RAID in the BIOS... install perform OK (at least until now, YOU security update is on process)
Is there a way to be able to use RAID on this computer without buying another RAID controller ?
Is there a special driver I should download and use during install instead of the standards one ?
Is SuSE 9.2 correcting the problem ?
I would be grateful for any help or advice...this is my first RAID configuration (and my firsts SATA disks !!). Mirroring is most wanted in this situation, since the server will be a data server for all the department.
Thanks to everyone
Matthias __________________________________
Matthias Titeux, PhD INSERM U563 - CPTP Departement de Genetique fonctionnelle des maladies des epitheliums Batiment Lefebvre - 2eme etage CHU Purpan Avenue de Grande Bretagne 31059 Toulouse Cedex 03 FRANCE --------------- Tel: 33 (5) 62 74 45 03 _________________________________
-- Check the headers for your unsubscription address For additional commands send e-mail to suse-linux-e-help@suse.com Also check the archives at http://lists.suse.com Please read the FAQs: suse-linux-e-faq@suse.com
On Thu, 23 Dec 2004 18:53:26 +0100, Matthias Titeux <matthias.titeux@toulouse.inserm.fr> wrote:
Hi everyone Fisrt of all I wan't to which every one who might be concerned :
MERRY CHRISTMAS !
Sorry to the others !
And to EVERYONE (except chinese maybe !)
HAPPY NEW YEAR !
Now start the question :
The lab has bought a DELL PowerEdge SC420 server which include 2 SATA 160 Go HD... on an Adaptec RAID controller.
I don't know yet exactly which Adaptec controller it is but what's sure IS :
Both HD are not recognised during installation (Suse pro 9.1 DVD, 32 bit)
If i disable the RAID in the BIOS... install perform OK (at least until now, YOU security update is on process)
Is there a way to be able to use RAID on this computer without buying another RAID controller ?
Is there a special driver I should download and use during install instead of the standards one ?
Is SuSE 9.2 correcting the problem ?
I would be grateful for any help or advice...this is my first RAID configuration (and my firsts SATA disks !!). Mirroring is most wanted in this situation, since the server will be a data server for all the department.
Thanks to everyone
Matthias __________________________________
Matthias Titeux, PhD INSERM U563 - CPTP Departement de Genetique fonctionnelle des maladies des epitheliums Batiment Lefebvre - 2eme etage CHU Purpan Avenue de Grande Bretagne 31059 Toulouse Cedex 03 FRANCE --------------- Tel: 33 (5) 62 74 45 03 _________________________________
-- Check the headers for your unsubscription address For additional commands send e-mail to suse-linux-e-help@suse.com Also check the archives at http://lists.suse.com Please read the FAQs: suse-linux-e-faq@suse.com
Mattias, on adaptec's site for some of the controllers there are drivers for SuSE 9.0 and 9.1, and SLES 9. Also there are sources if you want to compile :) Here's the link: http://www.adaptec.com/worldwide/support/suppbyproduct.jsp?sess=no&language=English+US&cat=%2FTechnology%2FSerial+ATA&fromPage=driverindex If your controller is 2410SA or 2810SA, you are in the game. Sunny -- Get Firefox http://www.spreadfirefox.com/?q=affiliates&id=10745&t=85
Thanx to everyone who replied to my message. I think the controller not hardware RAID. It is software RAID, provided by the BIOS on the card.... so i ended up by using soft RAID ! The system is working, soft RAID is working... it will be enough ! Thank you again Matthias __________________________________ Matthias Titeux, PhD INSERM U563 - CPTP Departement de Genetique fonctionnelle des maladies des epitheliums Batiment Lefebvre - 2eme etage CHU Purpan Avenue de Grande Bretagne 31059 Toulouse Cedex 03 FRANCE --------------- Tel: 33 (5) 62 74 45 03 _________________________________
On Tuesday 28 December 2004 14:27, Matthias Titeux wrote:
Thanx to everyone who replied to my message.
I think the controller not hardware RAID. It is software RAID, provided by the BIOS on the card.... so i ended up by using soft RAID ! The system is working, soft RAID is working... it will be enough !
Thank you again
Matthias Ahh this is better than hardware, as you can take either disk and use it in any sata card, not just on a card of the same type!
Jerry
participants (5)
-
Bahram Alinezhad -
Greg Freemyer -
Jerry Westrick -
Matthias Titeux -
Sunny