I am thinking of buying a laptop to use as a second computer round the house - for my young son to play with, for my wife to check email while I'm working, and very occasional trips away, that sort of thing. What I want, therefore, is something that will run SUSE 9.1 fairly well, probably using XFce4 or ROX as the desktop rather than KDE, I'd guess. It needs to have enough grunt to cope with playing Flash games for my son, and other multimedia tasks, and it requires wireless networking. That being so, what sort of spec am I looking at? The thing is that a new laptop is about GBP650 for a basic model, but even GBP500 seems to buy a very poor second-hand machine by comparison (such as a P3-650, when the GBP650 could get a Celeron 2.4 GHz). Are there any dangers I need to be aware of when buying a laptop on which to run linux? TiA John -- John Pettigrew Headstrong Games john@headstrong-games.co.uk Fun : Strategy : Price http://www.headstrong-games.co.uk/ Board games that won't break the bank Fields of Valour: 2 Norse clans battle on one of 3 different boards
John Pettigrew writes:
[ ... ] That being so, what sort of spec am I looking at? The thing is that a new= laptop is about GBP650 for a basic model, but even GBP500 seems to buy a = very poor second-hand machine by comparison (such as a P3-650, when the GBP650= could get a Celeron 2.4 GHz).
Are there any dangers I need to be aware of when buying a laptop on which= to run linux?
Yes. You should do some homework and try to determine what chipsets are used in the laptop for the video graphics, ethernet, wireless, sound, usb, modem, etc., and check if an appropriate driver exists in SuSE 9.1 for each. While this is true for any computer, laptops seem to deviate more from the usual "standards" than desktops and servers. Unlike M$ Windows, which usually comes pre-installed with all needed drivers supplied; you have to spend some effort to make sure that the particular Linux distro and kernel can fully take advantage of all the features on the machine. For starters, you can use these as resources: http://hardwaredb.suse.de/index.php?LANG=en_UK http://www.linux-laptop.net/ http://www.tldp.org/HOWTO/Laptop-HOWTO.html http://www.tldp.org/HOWTO/Hardware-HOWTO/ http://www.linuxhardware.org/ There are more, search google for help. -Ti
At 02:26 AM 10/5/2004 -0700, Ti Kan wrote:
John Pettigrew writes:
[ ... ] That being so, what sort of spec am I looking at? The thing is that a new= laptop is about GBP650 for a basic model, but even GBP500 seems to buy a = very poor second-hand machine by comparison (such as a P3-650, when the GBP650= could get a Celeron 2.4 GHz).
Are there any dangers I need to be aware of when buying a laptop on which= to run linux?
/snip/ There is an issue that has nothing to do with Linux, but with the hardware itself. Actually 2 issues. The main one is the battery or batteries. If you buy a refurbished laptop from a reputable supplier, the battery issue goes away, but if you just buy a used one, the battery may become a problem fairly quickly. For me it became a very serious problem, quite a few years ago. I bought a laptop with _no_ batteries, and tried to put some off-the-shelf batteries in it. I was unaware that the original battery pack must have had heat sensors in the pack itself, to avoid overcharging. I melted the computer case, charred a tabletop, and almost set my house on fire! The second problem is the illumination system. A special fluorescent lamp, or lamps, provides the light to illuminate the LCD display. It, too, has a finite life, and I have seen prices for replacement lamps in the US$200 range. Maybe that has come down, I don't know, but it would be worth looking into. It is frequently possible in the US to get good deals on laptops that have been refurbished. These are usually "new" machines that had out-of-the-box failures, and been returned to the factory for repair and replacement. US law does not permit these to be put back into the "new equipment" market, so they are sold as "factory refurbished," or words to that effect. What you get is a new machine that has been very carefully repaired and tested, so that they don't get it back again! And it's probably not more than 6 to 9 months into the release cycle. I wish I could justify a laptop, since they're so cool, but I can't! --doug
Doug McGarrett wrote:
It is frequently possible in the US to get good deals on laptops that have been refurbished. These are usually "new" machines that had out-of-the-box failures, and been returned to the factory for repair and replacement. US law does not permit these to be put back into the "new equipment" market, so they are sold as "factory refurbished," or words to that effect. What you get is a new machine that has been very carefully repaired and tested, so that they don't get it back again! And it's probably not more than 6 to 9 months into the release cycle.
A couple of years ago, I bought a "refurbished" ThinkPad from IBM. Apparently, the original purchaser didn't even remove it from the box, before he returned it. I was able to buy it for $400 off the new price.
On Tuesday 05 October 2004 04:54, John Pettigrew wrote:
That being so, what sort of spec am I looking at? The thing is that a new laptop is about GBP650 for a basic model, but even GBP500 seems to buy a very poor second-hand machine by comparison (such as a P3-650, when the GBP650 could get a Celeron 2.4 GHz).
Are there any dangers I need to be aware of when buying a laptop on which to run linux?
Before you buy, I would at least take a look at the laptops sold by IBM on eBay. They are refurbished and most come with a 3 yr warranty. I bought one for about 2/3's the new price. It's an X30 and runs linux very well as do most IBM laptops.
On Tuesday 05 October 2004 01:54, John Pettigrew wrote:
I am thinking of buying a laptop to use as a second computer round the house - for my young son to play with, for my wife to check email while I'm working, and very occasional trips away, that sort of thing.
I don't know how much you are interested in spending, but HP has a notebook called the nx5000. Also, you can get cheap notebooks here, and they sell ONLY Linux, so you can be sure that their machines will run Linux. They sell their notebooks with Linspire by default. I actually went ahead and got a Linspire notebook, because I needed to play commercial DVDs, and as far as I know Linspire is the ONLY Linux distro which will run commercial DVDs. http://www.sub300.com I know that lots of heavy duty Linux wizards frown on Linspire because it runs in root. But maybe you can configure it to run in a user account. I am a simple end user, so I have no clue. I use SuSE 9.1 on two desktops and one Acer notebook that I bought super cheap. If you only need webbing and office productivity stuff, then probably any cheap used notebook will run SuSE 9.1. But if you want something that works out of the box for all of the features that you list below, and you don't want to do lots of handholding for your son and your wife, you really should consider a Linspire notebook. Especially if you want wireless networking. A friend of mine who is a Windows geek had trouble getting his copy of SuSE 9.1 working with wifi. I went over there with my Linspire notebook and he got it running zip zap.
What I want, therefore, is something that will run SUSE 9.1 fairly well, probably using XFce4 or ROX as the desktop rather than KDE, I'd guess. It needs to have enough grunt to cope with playing Flash games for my son, and other multimedia tasks, and it requires wireless networking.
That being so, what sort of spec am I looking at? The thing is that a new laptop is about GBP650 for a basic model, but even GBP500 seems to buy a very poor second-hand machine by comparison (such as a P3-650, when the GBP650 could get a Celeron 2.4 GHz).
Are there any dangers I need to be aware of when buying a laptop on which to run linux?
Mostly it's the peripherals. You probably are a more sophisticated user than I, and others on the list already talked about the hardware issues. But that again is why I chose Linspire. I wanted it to work out of the box. In addition to e-Bay, you can also get inexpensive notebooks here: http://www.bedfordmicro.com However, they sell mostly Win-enabled notebooks. In fact, I don't know if they sell ANY Linux enabled notebooks. But they do at least pack OOo onto most stuff.
On Wednesday 06 October 2004 05:59, Christian Einfeldt wrote: [...]
and as far as I know Linspire is the ONLY Linux distro which will run commercial DVDs.
Not "ONLY" :) http://www.turbolinux.com/news/040722.html http://lists.suse.com/archive/suse-linux-e/2004-Sep/4335.html -- - E - SUSE 9.1 | fluxbox 0.9.9-1 | G4 Dual 1.42GHz OS X 10.3 | VirtualPC 6.1 | copperwalls was here ;) "The righteous themselves will possess the earth, And they will reside forever upon it." - Psalms 37:29
participants (7)
-
- Edwin -
-
Bruce Marshall
-
Christian Einfeldt
-
Doug McGarrett
-
James Knott
-
John Pettigrew
-
ti@amb.org