On 2017-06-24 02:59, Patrick Shanahan wrote:
* Basil Chupin <> [06-23-17 20:00]:
On 23/06/17 21:55, Patrick Shanahan wrote:
* Basil Chupin <> [06-23-17 06:17]: [...]
What a lot of goobly-dook.
In Thunderbird one has to _deliberately_ use the Reply To Address field which, by default, is 'blank'.
If I find that there is one more instance of having a private post turning up in this public list then I shall simply and immediately send all posts from that person to the poo-poo bucket.
(And now, of course, every Tom, Dick, and Harry will activate the 'Reply To' option. Patrick, I will watching your posts very carefully :-) ) good luck. I firmly believe list traffic should *only* go to the list unless specifically requested otherwise.
What did you just say? Ah, "unless specifically requested otherwise". Typing in words at the beginning of a msg which state, "Private, off the list msg", or pressing the "Reply" icon and not the "Reply To List" or "Reply To All" icons doesn't fall within this condition you just mentioned?
no, what one types in the msg body does not affect on it's intended delivery.
No, but it expresses an intention: this message is private, I will send it privately.
and the *Reply* options still depend on whether "Reply-To:" is set or empty.
OK, look everybody, I think this whole thing has gone far enough and for long enough.
Attached is the copy of the Header (part of, ie) of Anton's post which started this discussion. Now, Patrick, how does what Anton sent me hold up to what you said above? Anton sends me a PRIVATE msg -- it is not addressed to me with a CC: to the list or vice-versa -- and so I press the Reply icon in my Thunderbird but my reply is sent to the list.
why didn't you just add text to the post instead of attaching a large wastful picture?
and the "Reply-To:" header you picture was from the list software, not my email client. and I do have the original.
No, that was a private message. See the "To:". So you don't have the original, either. -- Cheers / Saludos, Carlos E. R. (from 42.2 x86_64 "Malachite" at Telcontar)