On Tuesday 01 May 2007, Siegfried Wolkenstein wrote:
On Tuesday 01 May 2007 13:52:32 peter nikolic wrote:
That sounds very much like a failing hard drive rather than an software problem maybe you should get a little more intensive and give that hard disc a real goo test cus it sounds like a garbadge can merchant ..
Pete
Hello Pete,
This (hard drive failure) is what I thought as well. But consider this:
Kaffeine is recording in this home partition happily even after the crash. So writing to the partition is still possible. It's just opening and/or closing of inodes or files that doesn't work anymore.... Also other partitions lying on the same hard drive work perfectly (reading is doing well (executing ls and so on)).
How is this possible... Processes that wait for one specific broken sector get stuck in kernelspace and thus suspending or killing is impossible? Pretty poor behaviour I must say (to be honest I couldn't do it any better (kernelprogrammingwise)).
But still, how can i verify that it indeed is a hard drive problem? It could be a reiserfs problem, couldn't it?
How can I test my hard drive thoroughly? How can I tell the manufacturer of the drive that it is broken? They are going to test it and they won't find anything wrong.
I tried to delete some files and immediately afterwards the crash happend... After the reboot deleting the same files did work without a fuss. And I can imagine the files still dwell on the same sectors or on the same location...
off topic: I am very pleased with this mailing list... We seem to get closer to the problem, thank you very much! I can imagine this is a rather boring problem, because it could be some sort of "personal" thing not concerning SUSE (or Linux in general). But still it would be very kind of the kernel or the programmes to provide the user with some useful information, when something like this happens. This is what we can extract of this matter, just as an excuse we don't waste all our time on this rubbish ;-) To this is of course vital... so thanks again!
Hi . I think the best way would be to get the makers test suit off there web site , Which filing system are you using ? I use Reiser and find it solid untill you get a slight problem with the disc then the fun starts and these crashes you are getting are typical BUT having said that i have EXT3 on the laptop and i am just waitingfor an excuse to can it and get back to sanity of Reiser Cheers Pete . -- SuSE Linux 10.3-Alpha2. (Linux is like a wigwam - no Gates, no Windows, and an Apache inside.) -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: opensuse+unsubscribe@opensuse.org For additional commands, e-mail: opensuse+help@opensuse.org