https://bugzilla.novell.com/show_bug.cgi?id=856805 https://bugzilla.novell.com/show_bug.cgi?id=856805#c24 --- Comment #24 from qvacfcajdjw@mailinator.com M8R-2yr72d@mailinator.com <M8R-2yr72d@mailinator.com> 2014-04-01 14:48:07 UTC --- Again, please stop doing personal attacks. You are ruining your reputation.
P.S.; As mentioned many times before, each "work" in cdrtools is completely under one specific license, there is no license mix in sub-projects.
This is obviously incorrect. As mentioned above, mkisofs/Makefile is GPL licensed, but contains: include $(SRCROOT)/$(RULESDIR)/rules.top include $(SRCROOT)/$(RULESDIR)/rules.cmd these files are CDDL licensed. To all what I know of the GPL, you cannot just "include" a CDDL licensed file in a GPL project. The scripts are explicitely considered part of the "complete source code", and that is what the GPL applies to - they MUST be GPL licensed, too. For all I can tell, the critics of your licensing may be right! Given this situation, I will not distribute cdrtools (even if you continue insulting me, and trying to attack me personally by name). If necessary, I will setup a blacklist for the cdrtools package, and/or switch to a different distribution. Because as is, A) I have yet to see evidence of this issue being irrelevant, and B) you seem to be a person I do not want to work with. Sorry. Further attacking and insulting me will not make me consider your software ever again. Only a published, legal binding statement by a lawyer will convince me. No some fake organization like OSSCC.net, which is you again: http://www.osscc.net/en/impressum.html and which does actually not say that this mix of licenses is valid, but only that pure CDDL is considered opensource. But we don't have pure CDDL or pure GPL here. We have a license mix here. Oh, and of course if you would just dual-license the code appropriately, you could solve all of these issues very easily. But it seems that you do want these issues to continue. Why do you not solve them by relicensing the build scripts? Maybe, because you want to sue us later? I cannot risk that. I need a known-good license before I give a compiled cdrtools to anybody. -- Configure bugmail: https://bugzilla.novell.com/userprefs.cgi?tab=email ------- You are receiving this mail because: ------- You are on the CC list for the bug.