Mailinglist Archive: opensuse (924 mails)

< Previous Next >
[opensuse] Re: Suse 12.2 and Windows 7 (again) won't dual boot HP laptop

It would appear that on Oct 20, Jim Sabatke did say:

I've just spent an enormous time, again, trying to get my HP laptop to dual
boot. I have created partitions. I "fixed" Windows after using gparted to
create the partition spaces so that it boots. I used the Windows partition
format and sizing tool to create partitions that the Suse install could see
and use.

That might have been part of the problem...
Last I knew it wasn't a good idea to use windows tools to create partitions
for Linux. I've never had problems resizing a vista partition with gparted.
But that to, could have been part of the problem. I've been googling and I
came across some articles that don't think it's wise to use a non-windows tool
to resize a windows 7 partition. I do wish I'd found that before my first
reply. Because I know I said I'd use gparted... What I perhaps should have
added was that no matter which tool I used to shrink the windows partition
with, I'd have thought about backing up my stuff (probably with clonezilla)
first. I'm sorry I didn't think to mention that step.

If I had to use the Windows partition sizing tool it would only
have been to shrink the windows partition, leaving the empty space as
unallocated "free spaced". Then I'd use a Linux tool to create the Linux
in the free space. For example the partitioning tool the Linux installer uses if
you select the custom {user defined} partition usage option during the install
should work more reliably for this than a Windows based tool.

Or, assuming you left the new empty space as unallocated free space I'd look
for an installer option to install to the free space, allowing it to create
whatever partitions it wanted to {within the free space...}

The Suse install appeared to run fine, except a bunch of errors at
the end that all seemed to be erroneous and ignorable (like "modprobe
hid_generic not found").

That sounds like the OpenSuSE install wasn't completely successful. Which
could be a problem because the MBR (master boot record) most likely now points
to the grub or grub2 files that should have been installed to /boot &
/boot/grub on your new Linux filesystem. And if the installer was having
errors it might not have done that properly. Which could result in an
unbootable system.

Then, of course the laptop won't reboot, but there is where all of the "help"
sites I found online go in different directions. Of course, the Windows "fix"
disk I created gets Windows running again, but absolutely nothing I try, like
running "boot_fix" works. I can't really make boot_fix work because I can't
get it connected to the internet.

OK So you got windows running again. But the "fix" disk didn't do a good
enough job for it to connect to the internet. Is that right??

Well a lot would depend on what you mean by a "fix" disk. It might be that
it restored windows to a state before you configured your Internet access??

I've looked at a lot of searches and this seems to be a pretty common
problem, that some "gifted" people get through, and leaves everyone else
thinking there is no help out there.

Well I'm not so sure I'm exactly "gifted". I know that getting a new PC set up
to duel boot any version of Linux AND windows is something I find easier to do
than to explain. And I suspect that at least some of the truly gifted people
who truly know what they are doing forget how hard the documentation can be
for the un-initiated to understand. And it's likely that many of them tossed
windows off their systems before they ever got to find out what new devilry MS
cooked up for Windows 7 that makes it hard for people to multi-boot with it.

And likely some of them have been busy figuring out how to deal with the "UEFI
Secure Boot" that Microsoft wants to be enabled on Windows 8 machines...

I hate to recommend trashing an existing install. But if you can still boot
windows 7, but can't get OpenSuSE to run, Then perhaps the best course is to
assume that the installation failed. If you can still run Windows 7's partition
format and sizing tool, then you might try using it to return the Linux space to
unallocated free space. (Warning: This would destroy the files that grub needs
to boot anything with. But the next step I'd recommend should fix that.) Once
that's done you can try the OpenSuSE installation disk again. Only this time
use it's partitioning tool to create the Linux partition(s) from the
unallocated free space. You need at least one Linux partition for which you
need to make sure the installer plans to use "/" as a mount point. And it's
also a good idea to devote some space for a swap partition. I'm not the guy to
ask how big a swap you need however. Perhaps someone else will explain that

If you can't make the installer's partitioning tool work for you then:

While the hard drive space you intend to install to is in an unallocated "free
space" state you can look for an installer option to just use the free space and
let the installer decide how to configure the new partitions.

Hopefully when you try to install to Linux partitions that were created with
Linux tools the installation itself will complete without error resulting in a
fully functional grub boot capable of booting Linux and chainloading the
windows 7 loader on /dev/sda1...

Best of luck to you

| ~^~ ~^~
| <*> <*>
| ^ JtWdyP
| \___/

<< there's nothing like an idiot who thinks he knows everything, of >>
<< course, if I actually knew everything, I'd know I was an idiot. >>
To unsubscribe, e-mail: opensuse+unsubscribe@xxxxxxxxxxxx
To contact the owner, e-mail: opensuse+owner@xxxxxxxxxxxx

< Previous Next >