Am Samstag, 29. Februar 2020, 19:35:59 CET schrieb Sarah Julia Kriesch:
Gesendet: Samstag, 29. Februar 2020 um 02:21 Uhr Von: "Marina Latini" firstname.lastname@example.org An: "oS Project" email@example.com Betreff: [opensuse-project] Notes from the board on the recent thread
several members asked for a clarification and, even if we tried to keep the desired confidentiality as already mentioned in the other threads, there are not many alternatives to (at least) partially disclosing what happened in the last weeks.
What guided the decision taken were our community guiding principles and code of conduct.
"We value respect for other persons and their contributions, for other opinions and beliefs. We listen to arguments and address problems in a constructive and open way. We believe that a diverse community based on mutual respect is the base for a creative and productive environment enabling the project to be truly successful. We don't tolerate social discrimination and aim at creating an environment where people feel accepted and safe from offense."
For the second time Sarah significantly breached the guiding principles and how she chose to deal with this situation led to 2/3rds of board members believing that she should step down from her role within the board.
I did not breach the guiding principles.
Thats wrong. Multiple times, and you were already warned for this.
I wrote an email to the openSUSE Board because of a conflict on opensuse-project. I wrote that that has happened in the past really often with that person. Therefore, I had asked the Board for support. Gerald asked me for an explanation. I don't write to the Board without any reasons.
This mail for the board was not the reason.
Additionally, I am working with facts which have really happened.
You may have perceived it that way (as the only person).
Someone claimed in the handover meeting that some of the reasons I gave would be a breaching of the openSUSE guidelines.
Alternative facts are not part of our guidelines or Code of Conduct.
As all of you can imagine, this decision was not an easy one, and the board gave her the opportunity to try to solve what happened. Unfortunately the ultimate outcome was to offer her to step down instead of publicly removing her from the board per the openSUSE election rules.
And that is no demacracy! I had to choose between stepping down or you would remove me without speaking with me before about that.
This is wrong. Between the handover meeting and your stepping down was more than a week. You spoke to Marina, Gerald and me (and probably Christian) beforehand.
You didn't discuss that with me before giving me this "choice", and AFAIK Christian was also excluded from most discussions, and when he was involved, you already had decided and his arguments were ignored. He felt like his arguments were ignored. I wanted to solve what has happened, too. But you did not want to accept my arguments after the decision without us. So the only acceptable option for me was stepping down.
No, you could have stayed.
Christian was the board member against this decision and to our regret decided to step down.
His decision is understandable because your decisions are breaching our guidelines.
This is your personal opinion. The board tried to solve the issue with as less noise as possible, and in accordance with our guiding principles and CoC, and with the intention to avoid damage from all involved parties.
A real leader is thinking about his decisions in such a case. That is not easy. Most important questions are "Why" do I do smoething with "which reasons"? Do I know all point of views? That did not happen here. I was not allowed to explain my point of view. Christian was excluded during most of the discussions, too. The decision does not have any watertight argument. You can call that bossing instead of leading. And that is another argument for stepping down at the right time.
I will not comment your sidekick here. Given the special relation between you and Christian, his move is understandable. Everybody in the board regrets this move
Kind regards Axel on behalf of the openSUSE Board
-- Dr. Axel Braun firstname.lastname@example.org Member of the openSUSE Board