On Fri, Mar 02, 2007 at 10:52:25PM +0100, Alberto Passalacqua wrote:
After quite a long time, I decided to do some
considerations on the
status of OpenSUSE as a community and as a distribution, starting from
I'll start from some bug reports, which affects me directly and which
have been waiting for a solution for a long time since the release of
10.2 final. They're only examples, you can find many others on bugzilla.
* main-menu Hangs
The bugnr is incorrect.
* Banshee doesn't recognize ipod
* yast is still unable to list printers
* Gimp can't print:
to bug #226710, which is not accessible.
The main menu bug is a blocker and it's really strange no-one in the
development team noticed it during the development stage. A patch was
recently released on bugzilla, but it only partially solves the problem
for some user and does nothing for others, which indicates the issue is
It just helps to be insistent. And if there is no reaction, just bring
it up on this list.
Since you did not list the right number I cannot comment on it.
The helix-banshee bug is really a mystery. It's
there since beta stage,
but no solution is coming. It seems that recompiling a package is
impossible at SuSE.
It is not. Just the package maintainer (Aaron) seems not be as responsive
as probably necessary.
The yast-printer bug seems solved, but I still
can't see my network
printers in yast. I've just reopened the bug.
The gimp problem was marked as duplicate of a FIXED bug, but this one
links to an inaccessible report.
No, it was not. The other bug was referenced only. I just opened it
for your viewing pleasure. (It was a security bug and the bugfix was released.)
This issue is _SOLVED_.
In my opinion these issues are serious and the lack of
they receive is very disappointing considering that solutions were
promised in many occasions, and they're not provided in an acceptable
time (~3 months after the official release).
The bugzilla is full of other examples of problems which could be easily
solved in a short time, but never received a comment. There are many
easily fixable bugs with many comments and no solution.
It is also full of examples where we released bugfixes.
OpenSUSE, in the opinion of most users, is the mean
through which users
know SUSE, evaluate it and start using it. There are many users who
approached to SUSE through OpenSUSE to evaluate the enterprise line too
and to see how the team/community works.
I don't think OpenSUSE is giving a good image of itself neither as a
distribution nor as a team/community.
This is your view.
The quality of the distribution is lower then in the
past due to the
choice to release too quickly and the lack of testing.
8 months is "too quickly"?
Or do you mean the Alpha->Beta->Release turnaround time?
The problem is, that we also have business products on the side to do.
And you always want the latest and greatest, so long test cycles only
cause other frustrations.
Btw, openSUSE alpha1 is out _NOW_ while 10.3 will be released in August...
So you can already start testing.
The issue of testing was addressed by adding a beta
release for 10.3,
but I don't think the team should expect significant improvements from
testing provided by users if
* a pre-testing is not done in-house.
* no guidelines are given to community testers.
Well, we do publish the major changes done.
And _you_ know best on what _you_ want to do with openSUSE. We
necessarily do not.
* no consideration is given to their reports.
It is harder for us to publish fixes post-release as it is before-release.
Developers focus on the next releases, other products etc.
Also releasing fixes via online update requires additional QA effort.
Especially the pre-testing is important in my opinion,
users often don't have enough experience and knowledge, or they don't
test the distribution for enough time.
Thats because we release early and often now ... A paramount concept
Guidelines would help us a lot to look for problems in
and to test things more carefully
Everything you do should work ;)
Of course all this makes sense only if reports will be
time and seriously, hopefully before release ;-)
A final comment, to conclude this already long e-mail, is about the
GNOME-KDE question (seriously, for once).
Gnome users (not only me, there are a few, but there are) are quite
bored to see GNOME considered the de-facto second choice of the
distribution because it is less tested than KDE and less maintained.
Now, I understand many developers at SUSE love KDE and
that SUSE was a
KDE based distribution. But in the past at least it was coherent: KDE
was the default and SUSE was really optimised for KDE. It was so evident
that GNOME appeared out of place, and it was OK. A user who chose SUSE
knew it was a KDE distribution.
Today SUSE has no defaults, so a user thinks he can choose what he likes
more, but it's not that way.
In openSUSE 10.2 it is so evident a lot of the efforts
were put in
creating a KDE which is better than GNOME. Examples are many: from the
new kickoff menu, which was developed faster than the gnome main-menu
and has none of the issues of the gnome one, to the opensuse-updater,
which has no equivalent in GNOME (I know one is coming for 10.3).
Well, kickoff was developed on ideas of gnome main-menu ... so it had an
Both DE should be considered as alternatives, not as
rivals. I do myself
this mistake, I know. But it's really annoying to read "Use KDE" or
a KDE app" when a user asks for help about GNOME.
And WHY NOT? KDE apps work in GNOME, GNOME apps work in KDE.
I use GIMP regulary. I use Firefox occasionaly. Under KDE.
Moreover GNOME is the default on SLED, and having a
low quality GNOME on
openSUSE doesn't help to give a good image to potential customers.
If things are going to stay as they are at the moment,
I would really
prefer a strong but clear decision to make openSUSE again a KDE based
distribution instead of having a two-DE distribution only in appearance.
The problem in general is that our GNOME developers work more on
the enterprise desktop , while the KDE guys work more on the openSUSE
snapshots, for above reasons.
To unsubscribe, e-mail: opensuse-factory+unsubscribe(a)opensuse.org
For additional commands, e-mail: opensuse-factory+help(a)opensuse.org