Hi, I asked how to go about moving lilypond to factory on the packaging list and it was suggested that I ask on this list as well as a submit request. I've made submit request id 35916 already and here are my reasons :- I maintain contrib lilypond and multimedia:apps rosegarden4,rosegarden4 should "Require: lilypond" but because lilypond resides in contrib I can only recommend it in rosegarden because a new user might not have the contrib repo enabled. Lilypond used to be part of the main distribution and I belive it was moved to contrib due to lack of maintainer. I'm also not sure which devel project it should go to, it's a musical notation printing program, so I have submitted it from contrib. See also http://bugzilla.novell.com/show_bug.cgi?id=546120#c6 Thanks Dave P
On Sun, Mar 28, 2010 at 08:17:45PM +0200, Dave Plater wrote:
Hi, I asked how to go about moving lilypond to factory on the packaging list and it was suggested that I ask on this list as well as a submit request. I've made submit request id 35916 already and here are my reasons :- I maintain contrib lilypond and multimedia:apps rosegarden4,rosegarden4 should "Require: lilypond" but because lilypond resides in contrib I can only recommend it in rosegarden because a new user might not have the contrib repo enabled. Lilypond used to be part of the main distribution and I belive it was moved to contrib due to lack of maintainer. I'm also not sure which devel project it should go to, it's a musical notation printing program, so I have submitted it from contrib. See also http://bugzilla.novell.com/show_bug.cgi?id=546120#c6
multimedia:apps probably.
Ciao, Marcus
On 03/28/2010 09:56 PM, Marcus Meissner wrote:
On Sun, Mar 28, 2010 at 08:17:45PM +0200, Dave Plater wrote:
Hi, I asked how to go about moving lilypond to factory on the packaging list and it was suggested that I ask on this list as well as a submit request. I've made submit request id 35916 already and here are my reasons :- I maintain contrib lilypond and multimedia:apps rosegarden4,rosegarden4 should "Require: lilypond" but because lilypond resides in contrib I can only recommend it in rosegarden because a new user might not have the contrib repo enabled. Lilypond used to be part of the main distribution and I belive it was moved to contrib due to lack of maintainer. I'm also not sure which devel project it should go to, it's a musical notation printing program, so I have submitted it from contrib. See also http://bugzilla.novell.com/show_bug.cgi?id=546120#c6
multimedia:apps probably.
Ciao, Marcus
After sleeping on it, multimedia:apps makes the most sense. It doesn't really fit in with the other packages in printing and multimedia:apps rosegarden4 is the only package requiring it. I will revoke the submit request from contrib to factory and put it in multimedia:apps. Thanks Dave P
Op 29-03-10 07:16, Dave Plater schreef:
After sleeping on it, multimedia:apps makes the most sense. It doesn't really fit in with the other packages in printing and multimedia:apps rosegarden4 is the only package requiring it. I will revoke the submit request from contrib to factory and put it in multimedia:apps. Thanks Dave P
Canorus depends on Lilypond for printing, afaik.
(Sent to Dave by accident, apologies!)
regards, Jogchum
On 03/29/2010 04:29 PM, Jogchum Reitsma wrote:
Op 29-03-10 07:16, Dave Plater schreef:
After sleeping on it, multimedia:apps makes the most sense. It doesn't really fit in with the other packages in printing and multimedia:apps rosegarden4 is the only package requiring it. I will revoke the submit request from contrib to factory and put it in multimedia:apps. Thanks Dave P
Canorus depends on Lilypond for printing, afaik.
(Sent to Dave by accident, apologies!)
No problem.
regards, Jogchum
Another reason why it shouldn't be in contrib but in the main repo. Regards Dave P
-
Dave Plater -
Dave Plater -
Jogchum Reitsma -
Marcus Meissner