Martin Wilck changed bug 1187020
What Removed Added
Status NEW RESOLVED
Resolution --- WONTFIX

Comment # 1 on bug 1187020 from
No, we can't do that. I have put quite a bit of thought into this for
SLE15-SP4.

In particular the SCSI device handlers modules _must_ be loaded before any
probing of SCSI devices starts. The only viable alternative to modules-load.d
would be a softdep on scsi_mod, but that doesn't work on TW because scsi_mod is
built-in (sic). I don't think it hurts much because these modules are very
small. We could discuss reducing the set, only scsi_dh_alua (and perhaps
scsi_dh_rdac) should be required these days.

The situation is somewhat different for the dm-multipath module itself. In
principle, we *could* load it on demand. But we can't do it only from
multipathd.service. "multipath" is run from udev rules during early boot.
The tools themselves would need to gain the ability to load the module if it
isn't present. Currently that's not supported.

So for now, we need to keep the modules-load.d file.


You are receiving this mail because: