Ancor Gonzalez Sosa changed bug 1208437
What Removed Added
Flags needinfo?(ancor@suse.com)  

Comment # 3 on bug 1208437 from
(In reply to Martin Wilck from comment #2)
> 
> Note that the primary issue here is IMO that running the guided setup does
> not remedy the situation, although the error message suggests that it would.

Well. It suggests to run the Guided Setup to adjust the settings and try again.
It doesn't guarantee there is a set of settings that will work for your case
and your desires. ;-)

> It would also be very helpful if the constraints from control.xml were
> transparent in the guided setup. For example, if there was a label or tool
> tip next to the "enable snapshots" check box saying "enabling snapshots
> requires at least xyz GB of disk space".

That's indeed the main problem here. There is no guidance in the UI about how
each setting affects the size of the needed partitions. Especially the "enable
snapshots" one, which may have a huge impact (in the concrete case of Leap, it
increases the requirement for the root partition in a 250%).

Giving a good overview is quite hard. Almost any setting (enabling a separate
home, enabling snapshots, adjusting the RAM size...) can have an impact in
several of the proposed file-systems. And those impacts vary from one
combination of product+role to another. We are trying an alternative approach
in D-Installer that should make the implications of every change way more
visible. See
https://github.com/yast/d-installer/blob/master/doc/storage_ui.md#general-workflow

Of course, we don't need to go that far in YaST. Showing some label about
what's the min size for "/" or about how the presence of snapshots multiplies
the min size (as said, by 3.5x in the case of Leap) would already help people
to figure out what is wrong.

On the other hand and based on priorities, I wouldn't promise that will happen
in the short term. :-(


You are receiving this mail because: