Marguerite Su changed bug 1032849
What Removed Added
Status NEW CONFIRMED

Comment # 3 on bug 1032849 from
Hi, Jan,

Adobe Source Han and Google Noto Sans CJK are the same thing.

This typeface is a joint effect by the two companies. 

The only difference is:

Adobe uses Source Sans Pro for the Latin part, while Google wants to use
Roboto/Noto Sans. The CJK part of this typeface is designed to work with both
Source Sans Pro and Noto Sans from the beginning.

https://blogs.adobe.com/CCJKType/2017/04/source-han-serif-history-development.html

https://blog.typekit.com/2014/07/15/introducing-source-han-sans/

And Google wants you to prefix with Noto Sans to override the Source Sans Pro
part (the Latin part to be specific) 

That's how the URL you pasted reads.

The Latin part is just Adobe Source Sans Pro in both Noto Sans CJK and Adobe
Source Han. and their CJK part are the same too. Google just renames it without
changing anything.

AND:

openSUSE M17N maintainers (or Petr to be specific) have a fonts-config package,
which contains all the system fontconfig configurations.

In that package, we'll override both. That is, neither Sources Sans Pro or Noto
Sans will be used for displaying Latin. Every Latin on openSUSE is displayed
with the same font (even on CJK systems) that we choose by ourselves.

So considering that, this bug is valid. Because:

1. Google used Adobe Source Han exactly, just renamed to Noto Sans CJK.

2. Google prefixed it with Noto Sans to get what they want. it's a workaround.
the font is still the same.

Personally I think the best way to fix this is to strip CJK part entirely from
the packages mentioned in this report. And let Google Noto provides it (because
the later has a full coverage right now, this will save you a lot of work).


Greetings

Marguerite


You are receiving this mail because: