Comment # 52 on bug 1226122 from Felix Miata
(In reply to Martin Wilck from comment #51)
> Anyway, I understand that neither you nor Felix like my suggestion from
> comment 42
...
> note that with
> systemd-boot the ESP will be a much more important piece of the Linux
> installation, and not mounting it under Linux at all just won't work, AFAIU.

I don't expect to live long enough to see grub2-efi no longer supported.

(In reply to Martin Wilck from comment #42)
> Mario/Felix, have you considered to install just any bootloader but leave
> the option "Update NVRAM entry" switched off? I think this might just do
> what you want (not certain though).

It's neither KISS nor green, having bootloaders on every installation in
multiboot environments. Multiple bootloaders offer an unnecessary avenue for a
spontaneous appearance of some bug that causes a heap of hurt and lost time fo
fix, meanwhile wasting bandwidth and media write cycles.

Mine are not just PCs, but also, in a fashion, archives. Many installations are
kept bootable well beyond their support lives, e.g.:
# lsblk -o NAME,LABEL,MOUNTPOINT
NAME    LABEL        MOUNTPOINT
sda
├─sda1
├─sda2
├─sda3  boot03i256   /disks/boot
├─sda4
├─sda5  05swapi256   [SWAP]
├─sda6
├─sda7
├─sda8  s131p08i256  /disks/s131
├─sda9  home09i256   /home
├─sda10 s423p10i256  /disks/s423
├─sda11 pub11i256    /pub
├─sda12 ulcl12i256   /usr/local
├─sda13 i256trixie
├─sda14 i256p14f40   /disks/f40
├─sda15 mga6p15i256
├─sda16 s123p16i256
├─sda17 s122p17i256
├─sda18 mga9p18i256  /disks/mga9
├─sda19 i256p19sslo
├─sda20 i256p20f38
├─sda21 s114p21i256  /disks/s114
├─sda22 s132p22i256
├─sda23 sTWp23i256   /disks/stw
├─sda24 i256bookworm
├─sda25 i256bullseye
├─sda26 ub22p26i256
├─sda27 s155p27i256  /disks/s155
├─sda28 s154p28i256
├─sda29 i256p29f39
├─sda30 s153p30i256
├─sda31 ub20p31i256
├─sda32 mga8p32i256
├─sda33 ub24p33i256  /disks/ub24
├─sda34 mga7p34i256
├─sda35 s151p35i256  /disks/s151
├─sda36 s156p36i256  /
├─sda37 fedovar
├─sda38 isos-i256
├─sda39 rootantiX16
├─sda40 antiX-i256
├─sda41 s121i256     /disks/s121
└─sda42 mga4i256     /disks/mga4
#
These are all pleasurably booting from 13.1's grub-0.97-194.1.2 with
penguin=100 gfxboot, same as my numerous other PCs that continue legacy
booting. What ain't broke don't need fixin. :) My UEFI's all boot via TW's EFI
grub, though with a much less attractive and convenient grub menu.


You are receiving this mail because: