Radomir Terber changed bug 911286
What Removed Added
CC   rara@post.cz

Comment # 8 on bug 911286 from
(In reply to IT wrx from comment #7)
> Please forgive my ignorance, but is this approach of disabling a feature
> that has a bug considered serious the distro-wide policy for opensuse or is
> this just the decision taken by you in this situation? 
> 
> If the latter, while i can understand the motivation, i would like to
> request that you reconsider. 
> 
> As an end user i would much rather the distro not remove features to make
> decisions for me/protect me from upstream. I would think a message during
> install and/or documentation of the issue in the wiki would be enough, and
> still allow people to use the software the way it is written, even if buggy.
> I've been using mc in Arch Linux for years and either didn't know about this
> bug or had forgotten about it, b/c i don't use "skip": probably b/c it
> deleted my files one time, and i said to myself "i'll never use that again,
> whatever 'skip' is supposed to mean/do". I use "abort" when there is a
> problem and i generally try to make sure perms are correct, etc before
> trying transfers. 
> 
> As buggy as it might be, i would imagine that ssh shell via mc is a
> important feature for many remote LSAs, and was shocked to find this has
> been stripped in a distro that advertises itself as a good fit for devs,
> admins, etc.
> 
> thanks.

I definitely agree with it. Even if I am not in necessary detail about this
bug, all other distros known to me use this feature and it doesn't seems that
they have any issue. 
So it SHOULD stay preserved here (with - for example - security warning during
installation), or at least offer alternatives (with / without this feature). 
It decreases  whole distro in my eyes.


You are receiving this mail because: