On Monday 14 October 2002 14:43, Graham Murray wrote:
Kevin McLauchlan <kevinmcl@magma.ca> writes:
This arrangement got duplicated when office e-mail came along. Sometimes, people respond to a multi-point e-mail by "My comments are embedded, below". Otherwise, they add their two-cents worth at the top, so that busy executives and managers can see the latest at a glance.
Therefore, MS Outlook and other Windows mail readers tend to default to that model of message trail handling.
NO they did not! What they did is analogous to exchanging letters by post and each correspondent photocopying the previous correspondence, adding their new material and sending it all in the envelope. Passing correspondence files around is fine within an office or even an organisation, but when sending letters it is more normal to put a reference to previous correspondence at the top of the letter. (In business) Both the sender and recipient maintain they own files containing the correspondence.
The traditional email paradigm follows this system. It contains "In-Reply-To:" and/or "References" headers which are analogous to the both the references at the top of (paper) mail and the index in the correspondence file. As both sender and recipient have (local) copies replies should only quote sufficient to give context rather than repeating the whole "bundle". "High Quality" mail readers maintain the thread "tree" and allow the reader to easily refer back to previous correspondence.
Not only is what Graham says correct, but to keep it really simple...Would *anyone* want a business run by a "busy executive" who has no time to make sure his "latest glance" at a post, is following the exact same thread and/or hasn't been altered to show a different point of view (or whatever) by someone else also in the thread? If this is how businesses are run, no wonder all the touble with greedy corporations now beginning to get burned by the law...the "busy executives and managers" didn't take the time to do their jobs properly because they didn't give a crud about time honored and practical traditions. John -- Linux...the freedom to do what *YOU* want, with *YOUR* computer. M$...we'll tell you what you need and we'll bleed you dry doing it you thief!