Hello Satoru Matsumoto and Sankar, thanks for your replies. I want to answere to Satoru Matsumoto mosly as a election comitee member. ... Am 22.01.11, 04:47 +0900 schrieb Satoru Matsumoto:
Kai-Uwe Behrmann wrote:
After rereading the thread, I found the statement of Satoru Matsumoto. Now I realise, he is in the election comitee and stated probably the comitees opinion early. But that was not clear of at all. However for a election to work properly the old board can not justice over a candidate. Thats clearly a no no. The election comitee moved its native responsibility in the arms of the enemy of the candidate. The downbulling of the candidate showed clearly, there is a conflict with more than one person in the board. I have looked into the look files. xxxxxx was banned and kicked out of IRC without immediate reasoning. In my eyes thats down bulling on the side of the administrator. Shurely not the only case in the net. But I never saw such before and it took me time to realise what happened.
Did you call me? :-)
Please remember, I'm both a part of election committee and a Member. When I stated something as a part of election committee, I started with the phrase "as one of the election committee members, I ...". The rest
Ah good, these distinction in roles where not yet clear to me.
of the time, please consider my words as my personal opinions. And the answer from the election committee to your question has been posted by Thomas. As one of the election committee members, I don't have anything to add.
The election comitee acts as a formal control over the old board and the potential new one. The election comitees task is as well to protect the fairness of the election. We have seen a clear conflict between old board members and a candidate. The election comitee decided to abandon one candidate to the old board, where it had the chance to protect this candidate in front of the old board.
I hope some can understand my concerns now better. At least I saw a sign in Satoru Matsumoto email that this should be corrected in the rules to not repeat in the future. For now its not better.
So, please read the followings as my personal opinion.
As I wrote in another post, there's no one who became happy in this matter. If you really think this mustn't be repeated in the future, please give assistance to developing efficient way and rules, not to get rid of persons, but to get rid of trollish and poisonous behaviors.
The most disappointing thing for me is, we couldn't change The Person's behavior before this worst ending. Not only Board, but also everyone who could have a chance to change The Person's behavior should take responsibility for this matter. We have to promise this will never happen again.
I tried in my later emails at least to outline, how to preserve the fairness of the election. kind regards Kai-Uwe Behrmann -- developing for colour management www.behrmann.name + www.oyranos.org -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: opensuse-project+unsubscribe@opensuse.org For additional commands, e-mail: opensuse-project+help@opensuse.org