Mailinglist Archive: opensuse-features (291 mails)

< Previous Next >
[openFATE 308497] Update to GRUB v2
  • From: fate_noreply@xxxxxxx
  • Date: Tue, 11 May 2010 06:53:40 +0200 (CEST)
  • Message-id: <feature-308497-26@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Feature changed by: coly li (colyli)
Feature #308497, revision 26
Title: Update to GRUB v2

openSUSE-11.3: Evaluation
Requester: Important

Info Provider: Jakub Rusinek (liviopl)
Requested by: Jeff Mahoney (jeff_mahoney)
Partner organization:

Every single bug or feature that anyone has developed for GRUB 0.97 has
been rejected by the upstream project in favor of using GRUB 2. There
has been resisitence in the distribution community to switching boot
loaders, but this stalemate isn't going to go away. The code itself
isn't well written or well maintained. Adding a new feature involves
jumping through a lot of hoops that may or may not work even if you
manage to work around all the runtime limitations. For example, a fs
implementation has a static buffer it can use for memory management.
It's only 32k. For complex file systems, or even a simple journaled
file system, we run into problems (like the reiserfs taking forever to
load bug) because we don't have enough memory to do block mapping for
the journal so it needs to scan it for every metadata read. (Yeah,
GRUB v2 has a cleaner design, is modular, and it has support for
multiple architectures including i386, x86-64, and powerpc. Support for
ia64 is said to be forthcoming. EFI support is already there. More
importantly, it supports far more file systems and has native MD RAID
and LVM support. Adding support for a new file system is much easier,
cleaner, and has fewer limitations than with GRUB 0.97.

Business case (Partner benefit):
* Supportability - upstream bug fixes and development community
* Features - better fs support, native RAID and LVM support

#1: Robert Davies (robopensuse) (2009-12-12 14:11:06)
The main issue with GRUB2 (trying it out with Kubuntu-9.10) seems that
the simple text config file "/boot/grub/menu.list" is replaced by
scripts in /etc/grub.d, so GRUB menu configuration is less obvious and
more auto-magical.  Changing order of entries, and customising the menu
becomes indirect, though it would appear possible to "simply" use the
40_custom script and disable the other scripts, which handle entries
for updated kernels.  Altering kernel options is done in similar way to
/etc/sysconfig files which allow setting of variables.
YaST Bootloader module would need reworking to be focussed on option
tweaks and listing installed kernels, and other OS's found.

#2: Michael Löffler (michl19) (2010-02-10 18:30:51)
Would we have a maintainer for GRUB2?

#3: Jakub Rusinek (liviopl) (2010-02-10 19:22:36)
Better appearance, localization... It's worth it.

#6: Stephan Kulow (coolo) (2010-03-03 12:54:43) (reply to #3)
are you willing to (co-)maintain it?

#7: Jakub Rusinek (liviopl) (2010-03-03 13:54:08) (reply to #6)
What do you mean exactly? That I could be in charge of packaging it?
This is something I could do. Then it's easy to try using SUSE Studio
:) .

#8: Andreas Jaeger (a_jaeger) (2010-03-03 14:05:44) (reply to #7)
I think Stephan points to

#9: Jakub Rusinek (liviopl) (2010-03-03 14:08:55) (reply to #8)
So I have to test on my LiveDVD and if I have time, I will.

+ #12: coly li (colyli) (2010-05-11 06:53:24) (reply to #6)
+ I'd like to maintain or comaintain this package. I mean packaging and
+ bug fixes, or new feature. In GSoC 2008, I have a little experience in
+ GRUB 0.97. For GRUBv2, it's new code, anyway I still can show my love
+ to her :-)

#10: Robert H. Williams (robhwill) (2010-04-24 08:12:58)
Hooray!!  grub 0.97.......bye-bye!!! I look forward to this; I'm
willing to type/format/post
all documentation for grub2 for openSuSE.  (Not a coder, but I'd like
to help!)
Take care.  Have A Healthy, Prosperous Day!  --- rob

#11: Bayard Coolidge (n1ho) (2010-05-08 02:05:04)
I would love to see it made available as long as it can boot existing
systems on other drives; I installed Ubuntu to a 1TB USB drive, and it
works fine under Ubuntu, but it won't boot Windows XP or openSUSE 11.2
that are already installed on the internal hard drives.

openSUSE Feature:

< Previous Next >
This Thread