Grip fails rip on SCSI CDROM after 2.6.8-24.10 upgrade (9.2)
[SUSE Linux 9.2 Professional] After the kernel upgrade to 2.6.8-24.10, Grip no longer will rip audio CDs. The Rip: progress indicator only blips for an instant than goes to Idle status. The Enc: progress indicator goes through all the tracks, spending approx 2-3 seconds on each track then finishes as if all was OK. However, no files are generated at all! Some clues: - Syslog has messages: "Dec 29 15:32:35 xxxxx kernel: sr0: CDROM not ready. Make sure there is a disc in the drive." - Running strace on Grip shows the following (in one of the threads): "write(20, "Unable to open cdrom drive.\n", 28) = 28" However, the open on /dev/sg0 succeeds earlier in the trace. All of the needed devices have appropriate permissions: - /dev/scd0 - /dev/sg0 I am using Grip's buil-in cdparanoia for ripping. Has anyone else encountered this? Everything was working just fine last week and there have been no hardware changes. I can find no other error messages!?! BTW, this system has all of the 9.2 security patches installed (via YOU). BTW, anyone know of any other audio CD rippers/encoders? Thanks, Phil -- Philip Amadeo Saeli SuSE Linux 9.2 psaeli@zorodyne.com
On Wed, 2004-12-29 at 16:01 -0800, Philip Amadeo Saeli wrote:
[SUSE Linux 9.2 Professional]
After the kernel upgrade to 2.6.8-24.10, Grip no longer will rip audio CDs. The Rip: progress indicator only blips for an instant than goes to Idle status. The Enc: progress indicator goes through all the tracks, spending approx 2-3 seconds on each track then finishes as if all was OK. However, no files are generated at all!
Some clues: - Syslog has messages:
"Dec 29 15:32:35 xxxxx kernel: sr0: CDROM not ready. Make sure there is a disc in the drive."
I use a commercial encoder but my copy of grip on 9.2 Pro works fine with the latest kernel. Linux papa 2.6.8-24.10-default #1 Wed Dec 22 11:54:27 UTC 2004 i686 i686 i386 GNU/Linux Ripping a CD as I write this in fact. Dee
- Running strace on Grip shows the following (in one of the threads):
"write(20, "Unable to open cdrom drive.\n", 28) = 28"
However, the open on /dev/sg0 succeeds earlier in the trace.
All of the needed devices have appropriate permissions: - /dev/scd0 - /dev/sg0
I am using Grip's buil-in cdparanoia for ripping.
Has anyone else encountered this? Everything was working just fine last week and there have been no hardware changes. I can find no other error messages!?! BTW, this system has all of the 9.2 security patches installed (via YOU).
BTW, anyone know of any other audio CD rippers/encoders?
Thanks,
Phil
-- Philip Amadeo Saeli SuSE Linux 9.2 psaeli@zorodyne.com
Philip Amadeo Saeli wrote:
[SUSE Linux 9.2 Professional]
After the kernel upgrade to 2.6.8-24.10, Grip no longer will rip audio CDs. The Rip: progress indicator only blips for an instant than goes to Idle status. The Enc: progress indicator goes through all the tracks, spending approx 2-3 seconds on each track then finishes as if all was OK. However, no files are generated at all!
Some clues: - Syslog has messages:
"Dec 29 15:32:35 xxxxx kernel: sr0: CDROM not ready. Make sure there is a disc in the drive."
- Running strace on Grip shows the following (in one of the threads):
"write(20, "Unable to open cdrom drive.\n", 28) = 28"
However, the open on /dev/sg0 succeeds earlier in the trace.
All of the needed devices have appropriate permissions: - /dev/scd0 - /dev/sg0
I am using Grip's buil-in cdparanoia for ripping.
Has anyone else encountered this? Everything was working just fine last week and there have been no hardware changes. I can find no other error messages!?! BTW, this system has all of the 9.2 security patches installed (via YOU).
BTW, anyone know of any other audio CD rippers/encoders?
Thanks,
Phil
Phil, For ripping, you might try cdda2wav. You can run it through Grip or from a command line. I then use lame to encode to mp3. Pete -- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Peter N. Spotts | Science Correspondent The Christian Science Monitor One Norway Street, Boston MA 02115 Office: 617-450-2449 | Office in home: 508-520-3139 Email: pspotts@alum.mit.edu | www.csmonitor.com ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I'm having similar issues with SuSE 9.2 (from a clean install with patching up to date). My HD is on an Highpoint ATA-100 (/dev/hdg) and my CDROM (/dev/cdrom) is on a regular IDE. I've had the identical problem with Fedora Core 3 as well on this box. In my case grip creates the mp3 folder, starts to create the wave file, creates the album directory for the resulting mp3 and starts to create an mp3. The resulting files are only a few kb small (incomplete) and the process seems to hang. When I try to exit Grip, the dialogue box claims grip is still busy. I have another box with a more conventional drive layout which seems to work fine. HD on IDE (/dev/hda) CDROM on IDE (/dev/cdrom) Perhaps the problem may have to do with the extra controller. I'd be interested if anyone has found a work-around. Marcel On Wed, 2004-12-29 at 16:01 -0800, Philip Amadeo Saeli wrote:
[SUSE Linux 9.2 Professional]
After the kernel upgrade to 2.6.8-24.10, Grip no longer will rip audio CDs. The Rip: progress indicator only blips for an instant than goes to Idle status. The Enc: progress indicator goes through all the tracks, spending approx 2-3 seconds on each track then finishes as if all was OK. However, no files are generated at all!
Some clues: - Syslog has messages:
"Dec 29 15:32:35 xxxxx kernel: sr0: CDROM not ready. Make sure there is a disc in the drive."
- Running strace on Grip shows the following (in one of the threads):
"write(20, "Unable to open cdrom drive.\n", 28) = 28"
However, the open on /dev/sg0 succeeds earlier in the trace.
All of the needed devices have appropriate permissions: - /dev/scd0 - /dev/sg0
I am using Grip's buil-in cdparanoia for ripping.
Has anyone else encountered this? Everything was working just fine last week and there have been no hardware changes. I can find no other error messages!?! BTW, this system has all of the 9.2 security patches installed (via YOU).
BTW, anyone know of any other audio CD rippers/encoders?
Thanks,
Phil
-- Philip Amadeo Saeli SuSE Linux 9.2 psaeli@zorodyne.com
participants (4)
-
Marcel A. Lecker -
Peter N. Spotts -
Philip Amadeo Saeli -
W.D.McKinney