Hi SuSE people Is it possible that you could either supply a fixed version of YOU or, alternatively and possibly better, open source it so that some of us can fix the bugs in it. It's now becoming almost impossible to use and practically amounts to a denial of service attack on a SuSE 7.1 machine on which it's run. It contains massive memory leaks and currently, with the number of patch description files available for 7.1 on the SuSE ftp site, it now allocates over 300MB RAM and then blows up if there isn't enough swap space available to handle this. For those of us with 64MB or 128MB machines it takes so long to run YOU that it's getting ridiculous. If you use ftp.suse.com as a source then by the time it's got the patch list downloaded, it's timed the ftp session out and it doesn't have any error recovery from this situation and you have to start all over again... and that's on a machine with 896MB RAM so it doesn't even hit swap at all! I've also used it on 7.3 and it doesn't appear to be much better there either. On 8.0 it isn't quite as bloated so perhaps a backport of the fixes to 7.1/7.3 could be possible? I'd be quite willing to fix the memory leaks if you'd care to make the source available to me. Just 'cos it's called y2bignfat doesn't mean it should be ;-) And, yes, I'm aware of fou4s but I'm of the opinion that if a vendor supplies a tool with which to patch their distributions then it should actually work reliably! This isn't intended to be a flame BTW, just in case it sounds like one! Trevor
Markus Gaugusch has written a nice replacement called fou4s. See Q14 of the FAQ for more details (email the followup-to). -- -ckm
Is it possible that you could either supply a fixed version of YOU or, alternatively and possibly better, open source it so that some of us can fix the bugs in it. YOU (and YaST as a whole) is open source. It has just a stricter license about redistributing changed code under the name YaST (AFAIR). All source
On Nov 15, Hemsley, Trevor
It's now becoming almost impossible to use and practically amounts to a denial of service attack on a SuSE 7.1 machine on which it's run. It contains massive memory leaks and currently, with the number of patch description files available for 7.1 on the SuSE ftp site, it now allocates over 300MB RAM and then blows up if there isn't enough swap space available to handle this.
And, yes, I'm aware of fou4s but I'm of the opinion that if a vendor supplies a tool with which to patch their distributions then it should actually work reliably! The reasons, why I wrote fou4s, are exactly the things you mentioned. Including the NULL reaction from SuSE.
Markus -- __________________ /"\ Markus Gaugusch \ / ASCII Ribbon Campaign markus@gaugusch.at X Against HTML Mail / \
Hi, "Hemsley, Trevor" wrote:
Is it possible that you could either supply a fixed version of YOU or, alternatively and possibly better, open source it so that some of us can fix the bugs in it.
---snip---
I'd be quite willing to fix the memory leaks if you'd care to make the source available to me. Just 'cos it's called y2bignfat doesn't mean it should be ;-)
AFAIK, it is open source, if you read the license, but not free as e. g. GPL. To put it very short (do read the original license!): Only thing you can't do (more or less) is earn money off it without SuSE's consent, whatever you change has to be made available as source code to whomever, the copyright to derived works goes to SuSE, and all modified versions have to say they are modified versions and who modified them (as well as exempt SuSE of any responsibility). SuSE people, please correct me if I got anything wrong. The sources should be on your CD's. BR, Gudmund
participants (4)
-
Christopher Mahmood
-
Gudmund Areskoug
-
Hemsley, Trevor
-
Markus Gaugusch